One of the first and most important steps in setting up an online business is choosing what products you’re going to sell. But if you need help deciding, nobody will give you a straight answer. If you Google “choosing products to sell online” or “what products should I sell online?”, you’re going to get back a bunch of articles on the selection process. “Don’t choose anything fragile or heavy to ship, don’t enter a market that’s too saturated, try to sell something you’re knowledgeable about”. All valid advice, but not very specific. For some reason, everybody is afraid to give specific product ideas. Well, I’m not. I know how frustrating it can be when you’re stumped for ideas, so I’m going to throw some at you. Keep in mind, your success at selling any of these products is going to depend on your personal decisions: how you set up your website or eBay store, how you market your product, which suppliers you buy from, and so on and so forth. These are just some ideas to get you started, and some caveats for each particular category.
Arts and Crafts Supplies: This is a big market, and extremely varied. You’ve got craft kits for kids, quilting supplies for the avid sewer, oil paints and brushes for the true artiste, jewelry and beading supplies, leatherworking, airbrushing, and a hundred other categories. I would recommend selecting one niche, say, scrapbooking supplies, and focusing on that. The nice thing about arts and crafts is, like any hobby, there are people who are willing to pay a premium for that Santa Clause-shaped hole-punch they couldn’t find anywhere else, or that luxury silk thread. But you have to be careful that the price of the item won’t be overshadowed by the shipping charge. If you do go the scrapbooking route, you would want to sell expensive items like albums and paper-cutters individually, but paper and ribbons only in packs or kits (say 50 or 100 sheets of paper).

photo credit: gabyalcantara
Christian/Religious products: A religious products website is one of those sites where you can take practically any product, customize it a little, and sell it as your own individual product. For instance, there are a ton of dropshippers and wholesalers who provide printed t-shirts, monogrammed jewelry, and customizable mugs, license plates, belt buckles, and the like. Besides selling the various religious books, music, jewelry, t-shirts, pictures, and cards that already exist, you can get your own products made with funny or inspirational religious images and sayings stamped on them. Religion is part of many people’s identities, and they like to display it on their personal objects. While the Christian market is large, it already has quite a few players; the Jewish, Buddhist, Muslim, Hindi, etc., markets are less well-represented on the internet.
Spa/Relaxation products: This is one of those product niches that falls in the “gifts” category, which means you can group products into gift packs and instigate effective holiday promotions. The other thing I like about spa products is that there are a lot of lesser-known product lines you can purchase directly from the manufacturer. They’re great products: all natural/organic/shea butter/smell like candy/etc., just not quite as well known as Bath and Bodyworks (not yet anyway).

photo credit: kafka4prez
Nutrition/Health/Fitness products: People will always want to get thinner, healthier, and live forever. Nutritional/health/fitness products are in high demand, and while many parts of the market are saturated, there are always new trends you can capitalize on. Also, like so many of the products on my list, they lend themselves to blogs, tips, and articles that bring people into your site.
Toys: Toys are another category with an unexpected number of niches. Porcelain dolls, plush toys, vintage-style ride-on cars, board games, educational toys, science kits, models… the possibilities are endless. Because it’s difficult to compete with Walmart and Toys ‘R Us, I would recommend sticking to higher-end, unusual items, things you can’t buy at the mall. The ride-on toys are a great example: shaped like classic cars, 1920s airplanes, trains, firetrucks, and motorcycles, they’re expensive with a solid profit margin, and they have the kind of adult-appeal that will convince Dad to pull out his wallet in a fit of nostalgia for his first Mustang. Remember, parents will buy what their kids like, but ultimately it’s the adults’ money. You have to touch them as well as the kids.
Jewelry: In many ways jewelry exemplifies the qualities you want in an online product: high demand, easy to ship, and expensive relative to its size and weight. However, people have a strange compunction about buying jewelry online. Often the actual physical appearance of the item is what sells them while browsing through the jewelry store. Particularly for items like engagement rings, people are extremely leery to buy what they haven’t seen with their own eyes. Also, the more expensive the item is, the more developed your image of security needs to be. If I was going to sell jewelry online, I would cultivate an image of class, prestige, and reliability on my website. I would make sure I had fantastic images that really showed off the products. And I would stay away from extremely expensive items, at least to begin with, focusing on items in the $50-$300 range that people wouldn’t be afraid to buy from a new site.

Baby Products: Because the baby market is very competitive, I would pick a particular niche in baby products: organic baby clothing, baby Halloween costumes, slings and carriers, bedding, baby shoes or hair-bands, something like that. Like any popular market, you need to know exactly what your selling position is. Are your baby items totally unique and unusual, the cheapest or most high-end, do they appeal to Granola Moms or Technophiles? The way to succeed in a competitive environment is to know exactly who you’re targeting and cut your customers away from the middle-of-the-road, trying-to-appeal-to-everyone websites.
Poker/Darts/Billiards: As long as beer exists, the appeal of poker, darts, and billiards will reign undiminished. In fact, poker has become increasingly popular since the World Series went celebrity. I wouldn’t try to go too high-end since these products are essentially games, but you could consider getting funky with poker chips printed with your pet’s face and dart boards adorned with your ex’s image.
Theme Products: Whatever strange fascination you have, there are probably hundreds of other people who share it and would absolutely love to find a website devoted exclusively to it. Fairies, dragons, butterflies, Smurfs, Panda bears, Monster trucks, aliens, Barak Obama… Build a website with everything Hawaiian, (pajamas, dishes, t-shirts, tea sets, socks, backpacks, cellphone cases, aprons, car seat-covers, lotion, bathing-suits, posters), and watch your fellow Oahu-lovers line up to buy. This works best if other websites carry Hawaiian-themed products (the demand is there), but you are the only one with a site devoted exclusively to the theme.

photo credit: metaldoll [is catching up]
photo credit: PedroCancion
Those are a few examples to get you going. Here’s some more:
Kitchen supplies
Sports gear
Nursing scrubs
Camping gear
Motorcycle apparel
Holiday-themed decorations
Hemp/Bamboo products
Dance shoes
Mineral makeup
Wedding favors
Gift baskets
Solar products
First-aid kits
Special-needs products
Raincoats
Lunchboxes
Massage oil
Posters
Hair accessories
I could go on and on. I don’t think any of these products are superior to the others; I think you could succeed or fail in almost any category. The purpose of this list is purely to give you some ideas, to get the juices flowing.
Things that seem like a good idea that I would stay away from:
DVDs/CDs: The world is becoming more and more digital. My husband and I recently copied all our DVDs onto our hard drive and threw away the discs and cases. With the growing popularity of Apple TV and movies, Netflix, and similar digital media sites, I would caution against setting your business up around a declining market. Licensing restrictions have always made selling these products complicated anyway. If I was going to sell CDs or DVDs, I would stick to a niche market like Family Movies or Japanese Anime.
Pet Food/Bed/Crates, etc.: Pet products are a big seller online, but you have to stay away from the bulky, heavy stuff. If you’re going to be successful in the pet market, you need to stick to the quirky and unique (think dog tuxedos, fancy bowls, cute toys) and the light/easy to ship. There is so much competition even among the niche products like all-natural/organic dog food, that you probably won’t be able to compete unless your doggie booties and gourmet biscuits are significantly different from what everyone else is carrying.

photo credit: Colure
photo credit: Alan Miles NYC
Furniture/Appliances: Again, too heavy to be tenable. I wouldn’t bother with large appliances at all, and I would only get into furniture if it was the extremely high-end stuff. For instance, I know this one supplier of patio furniture who carries the most gorgeous patio furniture I’ve ever seen: wicker tables that seem to float, bamboo chairs that look like the throne of Confucius. If I was rich, I would buy that furniture in a second, and darn the cost of shipping it. But keep in mind, when you go high-end, your website and service have to match your price point. This may entail a larger outlay in web design and a larger credit limit with your supplier. High-end may not be in your reach right when you’re starting out in e-commerce.
If you would like feedback on your product ideas, please feel free to email our customer service division at support@wholesalematch.com or post at the bottom of the blog.
Product Ideas, dropshipping, pricing and profits, product research, selling products online